SoundExchange’s Music Choice Lawsuit Resumes, The Gaps in CISAC’s Report, and MusiCares Shares Wellness Survey Findings
How The Music Business Works - Issue #87
November 12, 2026
Welcome back to How the Music Business Works.
A federal judge has thrown out the copyright lawsuit over Flo Milli’s “Never Lose Me” with prejudice, ruling that the plaintiff never held a signed exclusive license to the beat. SoundExchange’s seven-year-old case against Music Choice is also moving again, with both sides proposing a short discovery period followed by settlement talks, though a bigger question still hangs over whether SoundExchange can sue over unpaid royalties at all.
CISAC’s Global Collections Report gets a closer look this week, including what it leaves out. Without The MLC’s data, digital royalties grew 11.2% year over year, and sync fees and direct publisher deals fall outside the numbers entirely.
MusiCares has released its annual Wellness In Music Survey, which found that only 30% of music professionals can comfortably cover their expenses through work in music, along with gaps in health insurance and access to therapy.
And Spotify’s planned AI remix tool is drawing backlash from fans and the industry alike, with questions around consent, credit, and compensation still unanswered.
Here’s what you need to know.

SoundExchange’s Seven-Year Lawsuit Against Music Choice Resumes
SoundExchange’s long-running lawsuit against Music Choice over its “Music Choice for Business” service is moving forward again after a lengthy pause. The original suit, filed in April 2019, alleges Music Choice underpaid statutory royalties between 2013 and 2016 by leaving out business-subscription revenue tied to channels and recordings that were also offered in its non-business subscription. The dispute turns on how “gross proceeds” is defined in the statute. A court referred the case to the Copyright Royalty Board in 2021, and in December 2024 the CRB largely sided with SoundExchange. Music Choice appealed, and in August the court sent the case back to the district court on jurisdictional grounds. Both sides have now asked to lift the stay, proposing a phased approach with roughly 75 days of damages discovery, followed by settlement talks or mediation that would wrap up by early March. Still, a larger question hangs over the case: whether SoundExchange has the authority to sue over unpaid royalties at all. A federal judge ruled against that right in the SiriusXM case last year, and an appeal is now underway.

The Gaps in CISAC’s Global Collections Report
CISAC’s Global Collections Report is the best overview of how song copyrights generate income worldwide, but it doesn’t capture everything. Its digital figure includes data from The MLC for the first time, which accounts for much of the headline increase. Without it, digital royalties collected by CISAC members rose 11.2% year over year, a more accurate picture of the underlying trend. The report shows digital as the largest revenue source, followed by live and public performance, then broadcast, with the US, France, and the UK as the biggest markets by money collected. The report only tracks money that flows through collecting societies. Upfront sync fees, publisher-negotiated deals with streaming platforms, and direct deals with TV producers all fall outside its data, though some of that income still reaches societies through performing rights. Economist Will Page estimated that direct publisher revenues generated over $4.6 billion in 2024. The same split is likely to apply to AI licensing, with some income captured in future CISAC reports and some going straight to publishers.

MusiCares Shares Findings From 2026 Wellness In Music Survey
MusiCares has released the results of its annual Wellness In Music Survey, which drew responses from more than 3,300 music professionals across every US state and Puerto Rico. Between 46% and 50% earn less than $50,000 a year, and only 30% say they can comfortably cover their expenses through work in music. About 84% to 85% have health insurance, compared with 93% of the general US population, and more than 60% of those without coverage cite affordability. Access to therapy has held steady over the past five years, with 57% to 59% of respondents reporting they have received it. Among those who want therapy but have not had it, 45% say they cannot afford it, and suicidal ideation among respondents has consistently measured two to three times higher than in the general US population. The numbers are starker for emerging professionals aged 18 to 24, 79% of whom said they could not comfortably cover their expenses through music.

Spotify’s Planned AI Remix Tool Draws Backlash from Fans and the Industry
Spotify’s upcoming AI remix tool, expected to launch in early 2027, is facing significant online criticism. The feature would let listeners tweak a song, such as turning a ballad into a dance track or swapping the vocalist, with the results staying inside Spotify’s ecosystem. The Financial Times reported that Spotify is considering charging Premium subscribers an extra $4 to $5 a month. Some users have said they may leave for Tidal, Qobuz, or Bandcamp, citing concerns about AI slop and fairness for artists. The industry has questions too. The Future of Music Coalition says the key issues are consent, credit, and compensation, and asks whether backing musicians will be paid. Publishers are asking how remixes will be named, how ownership percentages will be split, and how they will be told a derivative exists. Spotify has deals with Universal Music Group, Merlin, Believe, and Kobalt, and artists decide individually whether to opt in. Spotify and Believe say each remix will link back to the original song and artist, and streams will generate royalties for the rights holders behind the original.

Judge Dismisses Copyright Lawsuit Over Flo Milli’s “Never Lose Me”
A federal judge in California has thrown out a copyright lawsuit over Flo Milli’s 2023 hit “Never Lose Me,” dismissing the claims with prejudice. Artist Shamar Deal claimed a $200 purchase on the online marketplace Traktrain in 2019 gave him a 10-year exclusive license to a beat used in the song, and sued Flo Milli, Babyface Ray, 42 Dugg, producer Gerreaux, Sony Music, and EMPIRE for at least $1 million. Judge André Birotte Jr. did not rule on whether either song infringed anything. The decision turned on paperwork: under US copyright law, an exclusive license must be in writing and signed by the rights owner, and Deal conceded that Gerreaux never signed the agreement. Deal’s lawyer says he plans to appeal to the Ninth Circuit. The case is a reminder of how much rides on getting agreements signed in writing.
Random Ramblings:
- 5 Keys to Music Attribution.
- Even the Biggest Songs in History Have Metadata Problems.
- The 4 Ways YouTube Pays Music Rights Holders.
- Is alternative music finally taking over the Latin Grammys?